obriencj

is a pile of bits

Brine on the Wire

I realized while hacking on the test cases for the promises multiprocess module that it would be really useful if I could easily pass along anonymous functions. So I threw together a new queues module for brine that provides some Queue subclasses which automatically brine/unbrine any passed work.

This got me to thinking about the potential for sending code between processes, or even between machines. Certainly powerful, but also hazardous.

One possible application of such ridiculousness is in passing higher-order functions around over queues such that multiprocessing can execute them and pass the new function back to the controller. I can envision a trampoline-like model that could cross processors or even machines. Of course that is remote code execution. And holy-shit is that ever a can of worms.

As had been suggested by a good friend, I could implement a signing step. When unpickling callable code it could be checked for a proper signature and an exception raised if something were amiss. It could use out-of-band key exchange or a certificate-based system… but I am torn as to whether I should be providing such a facility or if it properly ought to live in whatever transport layer a user comes up with. Should I rely on everyone else to secure their communications and to verify the messages being sent? Or should I do the work to craft a verification step that is in-built?

This is likely moot as I doubt anyone will ever use this – even I don’t actually have a use for it! The project only exists because I was once told “you can’t pickle functions,” and I thought, “the hell I can’t!” However, I feel that if I’ve made such a tool freely available (and I have) I should also take some care that it can be used responsibly.

There is a light-on-details TrustedPickle project, but I cannot help noticing it commits one of the major sins in cryptogrophy – unnecessarily re-implementing things themselves. And there are no tests cases. And it was last updated in 2003.

Setting up a pickle-like module (or wrapper) that automatically creates and attaches a cryptographic signature seems to be useful enough to warrant some attention. Connecting that to a Queue implementation that performs the sign/verify steps transparently would be simple enough. This may become another entry for my ideas page…


Note: I posted about this topic on G+ as well. I should probably have written it up here first… oh well, next time